Two
female Tibetan antelopes climb on a ridge 5,100 meters
(16,800 feet) above sea level, conspicuous against the
Kunlun Mountains in the background. Human vanity and greed
for the antelope's fleece has led to the poaching and
slaughter of these animals. Not even pregnant does are
spared, and the antelopes are facing the brink of
extinction. Furthermore, illegal gold mining operations
are rapidly eroding the animals' habitat. In July 2006,
the author visited their breeding grounds in the Aljin
Mountains to check how the antelopes were faring.
The
GPS indicated an altitude of 5,100 meters (16,730 feet). I
kept pressing my camera shutter, but my subjects, grazing
only 25 meters away, seemed unconcerned by my presence.
Never before had I ever been able to get so close to those
long-antlered, heavily fleeced male Tibetan antelopes (Pantholops
hodgsonii, 藏羚羊).
I was ecstatic. This just might be the closest leisurely
encounter ever. With female antelopes, we were able to get
no closer than 300 meters. Now these males were indulging
us with front-row views. This was a worthy trophy to show
for our odyssey, which had taken us 7,000 kilometers
(4,350 miles) thus far.
Then,
as if annoyed by our intrusion, they slowly strolled away.
Wong How Man (黃效文),
founder of the Hong Kong-based China Exploration &
Research Society, tapped on the accelerator just enough to
keep pace.
For this journey, Wong had organized a caravan of seven
all-wheel-drive vehicles, including one six wheeler from
the Aljin Mountains Nature Reserve. Our first destination
was a basin in southeastern Xinjiang, between the Qiman
Tagh Mountains and the Kunlun Mountains. With an average
altitude of 4,500 meters (14,760 feet), the reserve, at
45,000 square kilometers (17,370 square miles), is the
third biggest and the oldest reserve in China. Only the
Qiangtang Nature Reserve in Tibet and the Ke Ke Xi Li
Nature Reserve in Qinghai Province are bigger.
Brown-headed gulls (Larus brunnicephalus), Tibetan wild
asses (Equus kiang), Tibetan gazelles (Procapra
picticaudata), and wild yaks (Bos gruniens-Linnaeus) in
the hundreds greeted us along the way as we drove up the
cliffs and down the valleys. The remote isolation of the
basin has provided a haven where wildlife can have a
chance to breed and prosper in the breathtaking scenery.
We were all awed by the animals and the natural beauty. No
wonder Wong's China Exploration & Research Society
continues to support the Aljin Mountains Nature Reserve.
A flagrant disregard for life
Perusing journals written by adventurers in this part
of China, one can easily discern that 50 years ago, herds
upon herds of Tibetan antelopes roamed the Tibetan
Plateau. The
nomads there needed lots of stakes to pitch their yak-skin
tents. Back then, the stakes that they used were the
pointed tips of antlers from Tibetan antelopes. It is my
estimate that there were at least a million Tibetan
antelopes just half a century ago.
Sadly, it is no longer quite as easy to encounter
Tibetan antelopes in those spots. My pessimistic estimate
pegs the population in the early 1990s at 40,000.
When I first visited the Aljin Mountains Nature Reserve
in 1991, I immediately felt that animals in the reserve
still faced a daunting challenge to survive threats from
human beings. For one thing, the administration was
severely understaffed, a fact made all the more apparent
by the reserve's vastness. The reserve, operating on a shoestring,
did not always have enough money for staff salaries, much
less for patrols of the premises to keep illegal
activities in check.
There are poachers and gold miners in the reserve. The
latter, some operating legally, some illegally, number in
the tens of thousands, and they hunt large animals such as
yaks for food. However, poachers kill for money. They
covet the hides, or more precisely, the fleece thereon, of
Tibetan antelopes. The fleece is dubbed "soft
gold" for the exorbitant black market prices that it
can easily command. It is used illegally to make shahtoosh
shawls (see sidebar).
In the summer of 1998, I received a call from Wong. He
was in China, and he sounded desperate. "I just left
the Aljin Mountains Nature Reserve. I saw 706 dead Tibetan
antelopes. Poachers butchered them!" In June 2000,
two poacher gangs were found to have killed 907 more--the
discarded bodies were enough to fill a soccer field. Small
wonder that Wong called the poachers names that are unfit
to appear here.
"As a former photographer for the National
Geographic, I know the profound power of pictures. I swear
that I will show for the world to see the beauty of
Tibetan antelopes, as well as the skinned carcasses of
mother antelopes with fully formed fetuses in their
wombs," vowed Wong How Man. His story and photos were
published in the September 1998 issue of Rhythms Magazine,
the first Chinese-language magazine to report on the
massacres. Wong later got on the CNN and Discovery
television channels to tell the world about it.
A prelude to protection
Zhang Hui-bin (張會斌),
deputy administrator of the Aljin Mountains Nature
Reserve, is an old friend of mine. He accompanied me into
the reserve on my first visit in 1991 and
again in 1993. At the reserve headquarters in the city of
Korla [population 220,000], Zhang expressed his gratitude
to me for getting Wong’s article published in Rhythms,
which has brought more attention and resources to the
reserve.
By 1993 the reserve had organized a few armed police
forays in a forlorn attempt to sweep poachers out of the
reserve. Oddly, in early 1993, better armed poachers
actually pulled off a reverse sweep. However, with the
gradual improvement in official support from Beijing, this
kind of embarrassment has not occurred lately.
In late 1998, China's Forest Ministry issued the White
Paper on the Protection of Chinese Tibetan Antelopes,
calling for international cooperation to protect this
endangered species. It was announced by the signatory
countries of the Convention on International Trade in
Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) that it
would be illegal to sell or own shahtoosh. Many countries,
including the United States, China, and India, have acted
to enforce this regulation.
Nevertheless, illegal hunting and selling of antelope
fleece continues to be a severe problem. Notwithstanding
the fact that Tibetan antelopes are on the endangered
species list and are accorded the utmost protection
by the law, the black market for the extremely fine, soft
hair still persists.
Qu Wen-zhong (區文中),
a member of the expedition team, is a successful
entrepreneur and an avid fan of wildlife photography.
During a recent trip to India, he went to a market posing
as an interested buyer for shahtoosh shawls. A vendor told
him that if he was really serious, he could leave his cell
phone number and someone would be in touch with him soon.
The would-be buyer would then be taken on a zigzag tour
around the township--aiming to shake off any tail that
police might have put on them--before he and the escort
finally arrived at the shahtoosh seller's place for
in-depth discussions.
The degree of secrecy, caution, and suspense literally
rivals spy novels. Qu said that the going price for a
shahtoosh shawl has gone up to US$20,000.
A torturous journey in the
highlands
I have to admit that this was a most demanding and
tiring trek. The sometimes dull and
monotonous, brownish and barren landscape was hypnotic
enough, but it was made worse by the 5,000-meter
elevation. I struggled to keep my eyes open and ignore the
throbbing in my temples.
The journey was dotted with unexpected incidents of one
sort or another. From Urumqi, it took our caravan six days
just to reach the entrance of the reserve. Soon after we
set out, the fuel pump on one of the four-wheel drive
vehicles broke down. After a morning spent on a botched
attempt to fix it, we left it behind. Like
us, our vehicles also seemed to be suffering from high
altitude sickness, and maintenance and repair became as
important as our daily meals.
We came across the carcass of a yak close to the Kunlun
Mountains, near the western edge of the reserve. Dr.
William Bleisch, a team member and a biologist, examined
the yak's teeth and concluded that it was an old female
that most likely had died a natural death last year,
putting our minds a bit more at ease that it wasn't killed
by a poacher. In such high and desolate surroundings, even
carnivorous bald
eagles and falcons that loved decayed bodies were nowhere
to be seen, leaving the yak's carcass a rare chance to
decay naturally.
Scouting for prized scenes
As soon as we rounded a pass, we were greeted by the
blue water of a lake, ice still lining its shores. On a
pasture to the east of the lake some animals were running.
"We've just sighted a herd of female Tibetan
antelopes," we excitedly radioed the caravan behind.
Until then, in the back of our minds, we had feared that
we might have totally missed the breeding antelopes. We
worried that the antelopes might have changed their
timetable for arrival at their breeding ground as a result
of the omnipresent global warming. Now, we could heave a
collective sigh of relief.
Going past Bai Quan Lake and Tu Zhi Lake, we saw Muz
Tagh, the highest peak of the
eastern Kunlun Mountains, in the distance. We picked a
niche on the northern slope of Muz Tagh to pitch our
tents. This would be our base camp for the following few
days.
Though we hadn't seen female antelopes in large numbers
yet, both Dr. Bleisch and Zhang Hui-bin, the deputy
administrator of the reserve and a veteran of this region,
confirmed that this area was where they had observed large
herds of antelopes breed.
Their assertion was backed up by resident experts.
After several years of observation, staff scientists on
the reserve were sure that this was one of the most
important breeding grounds for Tibetan antelopes. They had
observed 15,000 antelopes breeding here in the last few
summers.
We saw herds of around 20 female antelopes. We did not
see many fawns, which stay close to their mothers. They
feed mainly in the early mornings and late afternoons; but
in winter and spring when food is scarcer, they feed for
longer periods of time. This is one reason why they can be
seen everywhere even during the day. In summer and fall,
when more food is available, they rest during the day near
lakes, on riverbanks, or in low-lying areas.
A perplexing choice of
breeding grounds
The locations chosen by expecting antelopes for bearing
their young baffled us. Lush pastures surrounded the place
where they mated. By contrast, all the breeding grounds
were wastelands that had some flowers and grass no taller
than two centimeters (less than an inch).
Why did pregnant antelopes come here to give birth? Was
it the barren landscape that attracted them for one reason
or another? Or was it to stay out of the way of their
predators? "This altitude is out of the range of wild
wolves, bald eagles, and falcons, and it greatly reduces
the chances of newborns being hurt or killed by their
natural enemies," reasoned Dr. Bleisch.
Standing on the ridge, we became highly visible and
scared the antelopes off. Speed is the major guarantee of
their survival. Their strong legs propel them to gallop as
fast as 70 kilometers (44 miles) per hour. Even full-term
pregnant antelopes can dash as well. Herbivorous mammals
rarely have this capability.
As humans invade their habitats, the antelopes are
forced to adjust their behavior in many ways. The
behavioral changes have become more pronounced in recent
years. Staff on the reserve told us that they were sure,
after tracking Tibetan antelopes for more than ten years,
that human activities--illegal gold mining and
poaching--have caused profound changes to the animal's
behavior. For example, in the early 1990s, female
antelopes would let people come as close as ten meters (33
feet) of them without being disturbed. But now, they flee
for their lives when a stranger approaches within several
hundred meters.
But if they move to highlands to escape predators, why
haven't we seen any large herds of pregnant antelopes? We
were now in the highlands.
Adding insult to injury
I wondered about the many fresh tire tracks on the
ground. Because the reserve's patrol vehicles could hardly
make it here once a year, I was pretty sure that many
other vehicles had been here just recently.
Sure enough, 20 kilometers (12 miles) west of our base
camp, we saw what appeared to be a new open-air mine. My
puzzle was solved. But those people were mining gold--with
a fully equipped mine--right in one of the most important
breeding grounds for the endangered Tibetan antelopes and
right under the nose of reserve officials. This mine
occupies an area of four mind-boggling square kilometers
(1.5 square miles).
Aljin, as in Aljin Mountains, means "gold" in
the Uygur language. Gold rushes dated back to as early as
the Qing Dynasty. The environmental destruction that
accompanied more recent gold mining activities led the
State Council of China to launch a crackdown on illegal
gold mining in reserves in the provinces of Xinjiang,
Qinghai, and Tibet. Consequently, illegal mining has been
generally curtailed. However, corruption is still rampant.
Ma, the owner of this mine, is a third-generation gold
miner. Through a retired high-level bureaucrat on the
reserve's administrative staff, Ma spent nearly one
million renminbi (US$127,000) for the permit to mine where
we found his operations.
The Division of Land Management of the Xinjiang
Provincial Government is charged with issuing mining
permits. Sadly, a series of corruption scandals has marred
that agency.
When Ma applied for the mining permit, the reserve
vehemently objected on the grounds that the proposed
mining site was too close to the breeding grounds of
Tibetan antelopes. However, the good judgment of the
reserve officials was no match for
Ma's lobbying efforts and money, which ultimately secured
him a mining license. Ma also borrowed passes from two
nearby legal mines. Those passes enabled Ma's personnel
and heavy equipment to be transported unchallenged within
the reserve.
We struck up a conversation with one of Ma's young
local miners. The young man proudly told us that he was
paid 1,000 renminbi (US$128) a month, and he needed to
work only one season in a year at the mine to make more
money than he would have earned for a whole year in his
hometown.
For
the poor people in the region, working in a gold mine
seems a reasonable way to improve their financial
wellbeing. I cannot argue against their desire to improve
their livelihoods. However, I do have a strong disgust for
mine owners and corrupt government officials who show a
flagrant disregard for the wellbeing and survival of
Tibetan antelopes.
Ma's gold mine in the midst of a significant breeding
ground for Tibetan antelopes serves as a stark epitome of
a new and sad reality: gold mining has replaced poaching
as the leading threat to this beautiful creature, the
antelope, in the Aljin Mountains Nature Reserve.
Adapting to the new reality
Still searching for a sight of a large herd of pregnant
Tibetan antelopes, our caravan had
to move further west now that Ma's gold mine had deprived
the antelopes of their breeding ground. What had happened
to the antelopes?
We moved along the winding bank of the Ugurlilu River,
whose headwaters spring from the Muz Tagh Glacier. Recent
snow had left the ground soggy--ideal for trapping
our vehicles. It became a routine job in our daily search
for pregnant antelopes to pull out our stuck vehicles.
On an open pasture at the edge of a huge tongue of
glacier on Muz Tagh, we finally saw a herd of more than
200 pregnant Tibetan antelopes. Not surprisingly, they
dispersed as soon as they saw us.
The animals moved further westward, where the terrain
rendered our vehicles totally useless in trailing them. We
had to bid the awesome creatures farewell as they searched
for a new place to give birth. I felt a sense of loss as I
watched them race out of sight.
Just then, I saw two female antelopes on the ridge of a
mountain to the south. They wandered around the area but
would not leave. This led me to believe that they had just
given birth and hidden their fawns in a safe place.
When facing danger, a mother antelope instinctively
hides her newborn fawn if it is still too young to walk. A
fawn instinctively lies motionless anyplace its mother has
left it. Since the fawn blends well with its surroundings,
it's very difficult for a predator to spot the fawn.
After hiding her fawn, the mother emerges somewhere
away from the hidden youngster but easily visible to the
approaching enemy. This attracts the attention of the
predator to the mother antelope and away from the fawn.
Only after the danger is gone will the mother return to
the hiding place to reunite with her offspring.
A newborn fawn weighs about 2.5 kilograms (5.5 pounds).
Upon ingestion of milk from its mother, a fawn can stand
up 30 minutes after birth and walk, albeit a bit wobbly,
in another half hour. About one month after birth, mothers
lead their fawns on a long trek back to their usual
habitat.
It took us a while to spot a newborn fawn of about two
days old--old enough to dodge potential danger. It moved
with speed and agility away from us and onto a steep
ridge.
As it disappeared from our sight, we knew well that in
about a month, it would be strong enough to follow its
mother and others in a large group journey along an
age-old route back to their habitat to join the rest of
the herd. Perhaps in a few years, this fawn will come back
here to perpetuate its species.
I could not help feeling a bit of regret that we had
not witnessed the grand scene of thousands of antelopes
giving birth. I could only leave it to my imagination to
conjure up how that scene might have appeared.
Zhang Hui-bin recalled a valley full of Tibetan
antelopes and newborn fawns, still wet, trying unsteadily
to stand up from under their mothers. I tried hard to fit
his depiction into a jigsaw puzzle in my mind. I also
figured in the delight that we had when Zhang and I first
saw Tibetan antelopes in 1991. He and I were concerned
then that gold mining, poaching, and the substantial
increase in the sale of shahtoosh would together herald
the extinction of Tibetan antelopes.
Back then, he and I didn't even know where these
animals bred. This time, however, we witnessed that they
had at least for now dodged the threat of poachers. We saw
the antelopes in fairly large herds, and, unfortunately we
also identified new crises and challenges
lying ahead of these beautiful animals.
For now, it seemed to us that the situation facing the
antelopes was an improvement over that of nine years ago.
As one of the mascots for the upcoming 2008 Olympic
Games, Tibetan antelopes are appearing in public awareness
campaigns throughout China, even along the remote roads
connecting this and nearby reserves. Hopefully, the Games
will bring substantive benefits for the survival of these
beautiful but endangered animals.
I had barely left the reserve when I started missing
these beautiful antelopes.
......................................................................................................................................
Shahtoosh: Shawl or
Shroud?
Shahtoosh comes from Persian, where ah means
"emperor" and oosh is "fleece." A
shahtoosh is a shawl, cape, or some other product made
from the king of all fleece, especially that of Tibetan
antelopes.
Poachers, in violation of law and humanity, kill
Tibetan antelopes, even ones on the verge of giving birth,
for their fur. All hides head for
one and only eventual destination--Kashmir, in northern
India--because Kashmir is the only place where raw hides
and fleece are commercially processed into various
shahtoosh products coveted by wealthy people in the
outside world.
Shahtoosh was introduced to Europe in the 17th century,
and it has been a fashion item ever since.
A fiber from a Tibetan antelope is about one thousandth
centimeter in diameter, or about three-fourths that of a
fiber from a Kashmir mountain goat. The extremely thin
fiber is a double-edged sword--it makes shahtoosh
extremely soft and warm, and it also takes more raw fleece
to make one shahtoosh.
It takes the hides, and lives, of three Tibetan
antelopes and untold labor to make one shawl for a lady,
and five antelopes for a gentleman. The upper echelons of
Western societies have taken shahtoosh as a symbol of
nobility, elegance, and status. But that doesn't change
the fact that many antelopes were sacrificed to satisfy
people's vanity.
In order to soothe would-be consumers of shahtoosh,
sellers claim that their products were made from wool
collected where Tibetan antelopes shed their fur. Behind
this smoke screen, Western buyers keep buying shahtoosh.
It is true that antelopes shed once a year. But the shed
wool would soon be blown away by the wind or else scattered
around as the antelopes move about. Nobody obtains
antelope wool this way, perhaps because it simply isn't
economical. It is much cheaper and more convenient for
poachers to simply obtain hides by killing the lovely
creatures.
Those in the shahtoosh trade may try to "soften
the blow" by telling the world lies like this, but
statistics don't lie. Over the last two decades, the
bloody hands of poachers have wiped more than 90 percent
of Tibetan antelopes out of existence. The population has
decreased from more than a million animals to less than
75,000 today, and unfortunately the figure keeps
declining.
Poachers ply their trade because the illegal demand for
shahtoosh has created a black market so lucrative that the
poachers are willing to take on the risk of being caught.
They seem to know well that law enforcement in the reserve
is stretched very thin, and they can bribe their way out
of any trouble if they get caught red-handed.
It seems to me that if consumers knew all the facts
about the daunting challenges those beautiful animals
face, the consumers would probably stop buying shahtoosh
and give Tibetan antelopes a fighting chance for survival.
|